While plugging the release of his new movie mother! to Yahoo, Darren Aronofsky dropped this interesting bit of casting trivia, which has us wondering what might have been. The Walk the Line star has traditionally eschewed blockbusters in favor of smaller, more cerebral features, but the thought of him playing Batman is intriguing. Around the time Aronofsky started working on his Batman: Year One movie, Phoenix had appeared in Gladiator, so moving from ancient Rome to donning the cape and cowl would have been an interesting shift. This also isn’t the first superhero that Phoenix has been associated with, as he was in talks to play Stephen Strange in Marvel’s Doctor Strange movie, but that role eventually to Benedict Cumberbatch.